By: Peter
Chris, I simply pointed out that Dr. Hankey is qualified to write about theoretical physics; that the butterfly lady is in no position to call him an idiot; and that the article contends that there is...
View ArticleBy: jenbphillips
What a lovely argument from authority, Peter. Dr. Hankey is qualified to write about theoretical physics Except he isn’t writing about theoretical physics, at least not in the sense that actual,...
View ArticleBy: Antaeus Feldspar
Peter, just because a person has a degree that qualifies them to write about a subject doesn’t mean that what they write about that subject isn’t BS. Jonathan Wells has a Ph.D. in Molecular and Cell...
View ArticleBy: litten
SO much time spend in critisizing a man who is putting his life in helping. WHAT are u doing for the ADIS cases in africa. sitting writing toiletpaper-role-long critics about people actually working....
View ArticleBy: Chris
Were you spending the last six months thinking up your fact free reply? And Mother Teresa was not exactly a paragon of virtue: It is in the hope that others may see the fallacy of this purported way to...
View ArticleBy: Antaeus Feldspar
SO much time spend in critisizing a man who is putting his life in helping. No, no, see, we’re not criticizing a man who is “putting his life in helping.” We’re criticizing a man who could be putting...
View ArticleBy: Vicki
Homeopathy might well appeal to someone who told her patients to offer their suffering to God, instead of giving them painkillers.
View ArticleBy: Alan
I advice you guys to read ‘Organon of medicine’ by Dr.Samuel Hahnemann… Please dont criticize a science without having full knowledge about it… And for those ‘scientific guys’ who need a scientific...
View ArticleBy: Narad
I advice you guys to read ‘Organon of medicine’ by Dr.Samuel Hahnemann… What’s it about?
View ArticleBy: David N. Andrews M. Ed., C. P. S. E.
“What’s it about?” Fuck all that’s any bloody use, that’s what!
View ArticleBy: Antaeus Feldspar
I advice you guys to read ‘Organon of medicine’ by Dr.Samuel Hahnemann… Please dont criticize a science without having full knowledge about it… Ah, yes, this is what I call “the haystack gambit.”...
View ArticleBy: Pablo
My first introduction to Hahneman was in Martin ghardner’s Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science. I remember that it sounded so stupid that I couldn’t believe anyone ever fell for that idiocy. So...
View ArticleBy: Alan
According to homeopathy, water can “remember” a substance that has been added to it, even when the mixture is diluted to the point that not a single molecule of the stuff remains. But how can we be...
View ArticleBy: Alan
‘Ah, yes, this is what I call “the haystack gambit.” “Somewhere in the works of Samuel Hahnemann is the absolutely solid refutation of all your objections! Now you stop your criticism of homeopathy...
View ArticleBy: Calli Arcale
Scripted? What, is it a work of fiction, then? Style is important. I’m an English major, so I understand that. But in a scientific work, it’s completely worthless unless the *content* is of value. What...
View ArticleBy: LW
I would think reading Hahnemann would require more than a second grade reading level. I doubt Alan has read it.
View ArticleBy: Pablo
If Hahneman’s description is so bloody clear, then why can’t any homeopathic supporter provide a coherent summary that doesn’t make everyone burst out in fits of laughter?
View ArticleBy: Chris
Actually, I have read much of the Organon, and it is silly. It is like a trip into time, and even Hahnemann says that the dilutions seem unlikely but then claims it works! Alan explain how syphilis and...
View ArticleBy: Seyedaghanoor Sadeghi
In the Name of God Hello to all you folks, I ,as a Medical Doctor, was skeptical toward homepathy, until I started studying this method of healing carefully and hard. Once I understood that homeopathic...
View ArticleBy: John Benneth
What I find so curious about people who represent themselves as pratitioners of “skepticism” is really how little of it they employ, and how predictable they can be in their beliefs. If you’re going to...
View ArticleClik here to view.
By: Orac
Mr. Benneth, welcome. Perhaps you’ll like today’s post by me: http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2011/08/homeopathy_and_plausibility_bias_versus.php Enjoy. Also, if you type your name into the Search...
View ArticleBy: Beth Zumann
Sorry, but you’re an asshole. Though you are clearly someone who likes to listen to his own voice (perhaps you should try some Lachesis)you don’t know jack shit about homeopathy.
View ArticleBy: Chris
Ms. Zumann, that was such an eloquent comment on the article. You must be so pleased! You remind be of a Andre Saine, a homeopath of some note. He claims that homeopathy works on rabies better than...
View ArticleBy: Lawrence
That’s okay Beth – homeopaths don’t know jack-shit about Physics or basic scientific principles.
View Article
